The Long History of Dictating Where Jews Can Live Continues

The world has a long established track record of telling Jews where they can and cannot live. It is a phenomenon that uniquely relates to Jews which continues to this day in the holy land.

Pluralistic World, Narrowly Defined

The “Western World” likes to think of itself as modern and “progressive.” Its leaders believe they have largely overcome rampant bigotry in their societies. For example, western leaders would never suggest that black people be only allowed to live in certain cities, or declare that gays be confined to ghettos. Even during this wave of radical Islamic terrorism, no leader would ever say that all Muslims should be expelled from the country. Modern civilized society would never tolerate such positions.

The “Western” pluralistic approach is not confined to opinions within its own borders. Wherever there is ethnic strife, western officials promote parties getting along.  In northern Cyprus, Christians and Muslims are urged to reconcile.  In Myanmar, the US calls for Muslims and Buddhists to try to live together in peace.

However, the attitudes change when it comes to Jews in the Middle East. Pluralism is passé east of the Green Line.

Jews are Treated Differently

Today, it has become all too common for Europeans to protest in the streets chanting “Free Palestine” in calls for the destruction of the Jewish State of Israel. University professors give legitimacy to Hamas, a terrorist group, which openly calls for killing Jews and destroying Israel. The leaders of the European Union call for Jews to be expelled from Judea and Samaria. And the President of the United States, Barack Obama, condemned Jews living in apartments they legally purchased in eastern Jerusalem.

While pluralism is an embraced ideal, the open tent does not cover Israel.  The western world that prides itself on fraternity, believes that Jews should be banned from living in predominantly Arab neighborhoods.  The modern culture that seeks a global community, wants to deny Jews the right to live in their homes. The progressive left which advocates for human rights, condemns Jews rather than Palestinian Arabs who fight for a Jew-free state.

Ideally, everyone should be able live anywhere.  Except for Jews who should be banned from living east of the invisible Green Line.

It should not surprise people that the Jewish State is treated differently. These same “progressive” countries have a long history of forcing Jews into ghettos and expelling them from their homes.  Dictating where Jews are allowed to live is second nature. It’s the Jewish “Pen Policy.”

Here is a list of the Pen Policy in action, after the Crusades. This list ignores the brutal slaughter of millions of Jews over that time.  There is no comparable treatment of any other ethnic or religious minority.

History of Expelling Jews

Many governments expelled all of their Jewish inhabitants, both on the local city level and on the national level.

Austria: Jews expelled from Vienna in 1670.

Brazil: Jews expelled from Recife in 1654.

Czech Republic: Jews expelled from Prague in 1745.

England: Expelled all of the Jews in 1290. Jews could not live in England for another 360 years.

Egypt: Jews expelled in 1956.
Israel removes Jews from Sinai in peace deal with Egypt in 1982.

France: 100,000 Jews expelled in 1306 and then again in 1322.
Charles VI expelled the Jews in 1394.
In 1420, the Jews were expelled from Lyons.

Germany: Jews expelled from Brandenburg in 1510.
In 1593, Jews expelled from Bavaria.
In 1614, Jews expelled from Frankfurt.

Hungary: Marie Theresa (still an all-time favorite leader among Hungarians) expelled all Jews from Hungary and Bohemia in 1744.

Italy: Jews expelled from Southern Italy in 1288.
In 1491, Jews expelled from Ravenna.
In 1492, Jews expelled from Sicily and Sardinia.
In 1494, Jews expelled from Florence and Tuscany.
In 1510, Jews expelled from southern Rome.
In 1541, last Jews evicted from Naples.
In 1550, Jews expelled from Genoa.
In 1558, Jews expelled from Recanati.
In 1569, all Jews forced out of Papal states by decree of Pope Pius V.
In 1571, Venice decides to evict all remaining Jews, but does not carry it out.
In 1593, Pope Clement VIII evicts Jews from all papal states, except Rome.
In 1597, almost all of the Jews of Milan are expelled.

Lithuania: Jews expelled in 1495.

Martinique: King Louis XIV ordered all Jews expelled from French colonies in the New World in 1683.

Netherlands: Jews banned from Utrecht in 1444.

Palestinian Authority: After massacre of 69 Jews by local Arabs, British forces remove remaining Jewish community of Hebron in 1929.
In 1949, after attacking Israel when it declared independence, Jordanians expel all Jews from Judea and Samaria and the eastern half of Jerusalem which they illegally annex.
In 2005, Israel removes all Jews from Gaza Strip.

Poland: Jews expelled from Warsaw in 1483.

Portugal: Some Jews expelled in 1483.
In 1497, choice of conversion or expulsion of all Jews.

Spain: Jews expelled from Seville in 1483.
All 200,000 Jews expelled from country in 1492.

Switzerland: Jews expelled from Basel in 1349.

Tunisia: Jews expelled or massacred in 1535.


Some governments did not expel their Jews, but forced them to live in concentrated areas. Street signs can still be found in European cities named “Street of the Jews.”

Austria: Vienna’s Leopoldstadt goes back hundreds of years.

Czech Republic: Prague has one of the most famous Jewish Quarters, which was created as a restrictive ghetto.

Italy: Venice instituted the first ghetto by papal decree in Europe in 1516.  Others were developed in Ferrara (1624) and Rome (1555).

Germany: Created over 1000 in Germany and Poland during World War II, including the infamous Warsaw Ghetto.

Russia: Jews were confined to the “Pale of Settlements” in 1791.  Jews were forbidden to live in 75% of Russia.

“Jew Street” in Obernai, France
(photo: FirstOneThrough)

The world has grown very comfortable dictating where Jews may live. It is well past time for Europeans to condemn the racist Jew-free attitudes of Jordanians (1949-1967) and Palestinian Arabs today, and adopt a pluralistic and welcoming approach towards Jews in Judea and Samaria.

In November 2015, in a speech about attitudes towards Muslims, US President Barack Obama said, “we don’t have religious tests for our compassion… We don’t discriminate against people because of their faith.” If only he and others held such feelings about Jews as well.

Related First.One.Through articles and videos:

Names and Narrative: The West Bank / Judea and Samaria

Names and Narrative: Palestinian Territories/ Israeli Territories

Video: Judea and Samaria (Foo Fighters)

Video: The “1967 Borders” (The Kinks)

Subscribe YouTube channel: FirstOneThrough

Join Facebook group: FirstOne Through  Israel Analysis

33 thoughts on “The Long History of Dictating Where Jews Can Live Continues

  1. Pingback: “Jews as a Class” | FirstOneThrough

  2. Pingback: The Illogic of Land Swaps | FirstOneThrough

  3. Pingback: “Ethnic Cleansing” in Israel and the Israeli Territories | FirstOneThrough

  4. Pingback: What’s “Outrageous” for the United Nations | FirstOneThrough

  5. Pingback: Was ist für die UNO „empörend“? | abseits vom mainstream - heplev

  6. Pingback: Obama’s “Palestinian Land” | FirstOneThrough

  7. Pingback: The New York Times Thinks that the Jews from Arab Countries Simply “Immigrated” | FirstOneThrough

  8. Pingback: “Settlements” Crossing the Line | FirstOneThrough

  9. Pingback: Martin Luther King and Zionism | FirstOneThrough

  10. Pingback: Heritage, Property and Sovereignty in the Holy Land | FirstOneThrough

  11. Pingback: Dignity for Israel: Jewish Prayer on the Temple Mount | FirstOneThrough

  12. Pingback: Totalities | FirstOneThrough

  13. Pingback: The Hebron Narrative: Presence of Jews versus Presence of Israeli Military | FirstOneThrough

  14. Pingback: When Hate Returns | FirstOneThrough

  15. Pingback: I am a Zionist. A Deep Zionist. An Amazed Zionist. A Loud Zionist. | FirstOneThrough

  16. Pingback: No Jews Allowed in Palestine | FirstOneThrough

  17. Pingback: The Cave of the Jewish Matriarch and Cultural Appropriation | FirstOneThrough

  18. Pingback: Examining Ilhan Omar’s Point About Muslim Antisemitism | FirstOneThrough

  19. Pingback: The United Nations Bias Between Jews and Palestinians Regarding Property Rights | FirstOneThrough

  20. Pingback: Anti-“Settlements” is Anti-Semitism | FirstOneThrough

  21. Pingback: Time to Define Banning Jews From Living Somewhere as Antisemitic | FirstOneThrough

  22. Pingback: I See Dead People | FirstOneThrough

  23. Pingback: Considering Carter’s 1978 Letter Claiming Settlements Are Illegal | FirstOneThrough

  24. Pingback: The Nerve of ‘Judaizing’ Neighborhoods | FirstOneThrough

  25. Pingback: The Building’s Auschwitz Tattoo | FirstOneThrough

  26. Pingback: English Lesson: Eviction, Expulsion and Ethnic Cleansing | FirstOneThrough

  27. Pingback: The Old City of Jerusalem’s “Settlers’ Quarter” | FirstOneThrough

  28. Pingback: Evicting 70,000 Dead Settlers From Jerusalem | FirstOneThrough

  29. Pingback: UN Doesn’t Like ‘Proportionate’ Israeli Reaction To Arab Terror Either | FirstOneThrough

  30. Pingback: How Many Jews? | FirstOneThrough

  31. Pingback: From The River To The Sea, Jews Will Be Free… | FirstOneThrough

  32. Pingback: The Anti-Semitism In Anti-Zionism | FirstOneThrough

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s