Names and Narrative: The West Bank / Judea and Samaria

The New York Times has taken more concerted efforts to balance the narrative between Muslims and Jews regarding the holy city and sites in Jerusalem. It has not taken such efforts elsewhere where it only uses an Arab narrative.

JERUSALEM

The holiest site in Judaism is “The Temple Mount” in Jerusalem, due to the fact that it was the location of Judaism’s two temples which existed from roughly 954BCE to 70CE. The Jewish King Herod built the Temple Mount platform specifically for Jewish use to ease access and flow to the Second Temple. To this day, it continues to be the direction of all Jewish prayer.

In Islam, that holy site is called the “Noble Sanctuary”, or “Bayt al-Maqdes” or “Al-Haram al-Sharif”. It is Islam’s third holiest site after Mecca and Medina, both located in Saudi Arabia. The Noble Sanctuary holds the Al Aqsa Mosque and the shrine known as the Dome of the Rock.

Historically, the New York Times would reference the names that both religions ascribed to the holy site, typically with the Jewish name first (the Temple Mount), and later in the article, it would use the Islamic name (Noble Sanctuary). More recently, the Times would use both names in the same sentence, and occasionally use the Islamic name first, followed by the Jewish name.

JUDEA AND SAMARIA

However, when it comes to other sites in the region with different names from the two peoples, the Times excludes the Israeli terminology: specifically, “Judea and Samaria”. For such region, the Times will only use the term “West Bank”, except if an Israeli is quoted using the name Judea and Samaria.

Interestingly, the West Bank never existed as an entity until 1949, and was never even referred to by the United Nations Security Council until 1953. In comparison, Judea and Samaria, which cover more area than just the West Bank, have existed for thousands of years.

The “West Bank” came into existence after five Arab armies attacked Israel in 1948. The armistice lines established in 1949 at the end of the war with Jordan became known as the “Green Line” as the line was drawn in green on the maps. The haphazard demarcation did not follow any historic, political or geographic contours, but was simply where the warring parties stopped fighting. The area east of the green line eventually became known as the West Bank.

In the years following the 1948 Arab attack on Israel, every United Nations Security Council (UNSC) Resolution regarding the “Palestine Question”, never mentioned Palestinians as a discrete people or the “West Bank” and Gaza as entities. Each resolution referred to the various parties in the conflict being Israel, Syria, Jordan and Egypt. The term “west bank (in lower case) of the Jordan” only showed up for the first time in 1953.

The term “West Bank” is an Arab artifice and highlights the short, violent and illegal Arab rule of the area:

  • It was achieved in an offensive war to destroy Israel
  • The duration of Arab rule only lasted for 18 years 1949-1967
  • Arab rule of the West Bank was never internationally approved (the UNSC never voted on the April 1950 Jordanian annexation of the area)
  • Was administered counter to the Fourth Geneva Convention (the Jordanians and Palestinians deported all of the Jews out of the territory)

The exclusive use of the term “West Bank” gives a false impression that the territory has a long history of Palestinian Arab rule. Further, in never using the term “Judea and Samaria” for the region, the UN, the New York Times and others, distance Jews and Israelis from lands that they lived in for thousands of years.

As the New York Times and other publications now give equal weight to “the Temple Mount” and “Noble Sanctuary”, they should do the same for “West Bank” and “Judea and Samaria”. Alternatively, it could use neutral nomenclature such as EGL- East of the Green Line.

judeasamaria


Source:

2014 NYTimes Noble Sanctuary first, then Temple Mount (11/19/14): http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/19/opinion/horror-in-israel.html

2014 NY Times mentioning Temple Mount and Noble Sanctuary at the same time (10/31/14): http://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/31/world/middleeast/israel-palestinians-jerusalem-temple-mount-al-aksa.html

(11/7/14): http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/07/world/middleeast/israel-jordan-jerusalem-al-aqsa-temple-mount.html

(11/23/14): http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/23/world/middleeast/mistrust-threatens-delicate-balance-at-a-sacred-site-in-jerusalem-.html

Only calling it the “Al Aqsa compound” and not the “Temple Mount” (9/17/14): http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/18/world/middleeast/unrest-by-palestinians-surges-in-a-jerusalem-neighborhood.html?_r=0

2013 NYTimes mentions Temple Mount and only later Noble Sanctuary (10/15/13): http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/15/world/middleeast/ten-jewish-men-arrested-at-temple-mount.html

(9/22/13): http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/22/world/middleeast/jews-challenge-rules-to-claim-heart-of-jerusalem.html?pagewanted=all

2009 NY Times only mentions Temple Mount (10/26/09): http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/26/world/middleeast/26mideast.html

UN mentioning “west bank of Jordan” for the first time in 1953: http://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=S/RES/101%281953%29


Related FirstOneThrough articles:

The Green Line

The EU’s Choice of Labels: “Made in West Bank” and “Anti-Semite”

Nicholas Kristof’s “Arab Land”

Advertisements

30 thoughts on “Names and Narrative: The West Bank / Judea and Samaria

  1. Pingback: The LEGAL Israeli Settlements | Gaasedal's Weblog

  2. Pingback: The Legal Israeli Settlements.

  3. Pingback: The Legal Israeli Settlements | FirstOneThrough

  4. Pingback: Nicholas Kristof’s “Arab Land” | FirstOneThrough

  5. Pingback: The New York Times Large Propaganda Piece for Israeli Elections | FirstOneThrough

  6. Pingback: A “Viable” Palestinian State | FirstOneThrough

  7. Pingback: Finding Mr. Right-Wing | FirstOneThrough

  8. Pingback: Names and Narrative: Palestinian Territories/ Israeli Territories | FirstOneThrough

  9. Pingback: The Israeli Peace Process versus the Palestinian Divorce Proceedings | FirstOneThrough

  10. Pingback: Our “peace partners” are against normalization with us | Anne's Opinions

  11. Pingback: The Past, Present and Future Narratives in the Arab-Israeli Conflict | FirstOneThrough

  12. Pingback: The Narrative that Prevents Peace in the Arab-Israeli Conflict.

  13. Pingback: Gimme that Old-Time Religion | FirstOneThrough

  14. Pingback: The EU’s Choice of Labels: “Made in West Bank” and “Anti-Semitism” | FirstOneThrough

  15. Pingback: Gimme that Old-Time Religion

  16. Pingback: EU’s Choice of Labels: “Made in West Bank” & “Anti-Semite”

  17. Pingback: Names and Narrative: CNN’s Temple Mount/ Al Aqsa Complex Inversion | FirstOneThrough

  18. Pingback: Recognition of Acquiring Disputed Land in a Defensive War | FirstOneThrough

  19. Pingback: The “Pen Policy” of Dictating Where Jews Can Live | FirstOneThrough

  20. Pingback: The New York Times on the History of Gush Etzion | FirstOneThrough

  21. Pingback: New York Times Tales of Israeli Messianic War-Mongering | FirstOneThrough

  22. Pingback: New York Times Lies about the Gentleness of Zionism | FirstOneThrough

  23. Pingback: Names and Narrative: Genocide / Intifada | FirstOneThrough

  24. Pingback: Names and Narrative: “Palestinians” versus Palestinian Arabs / Israeli Arabs | FirstOneThrough

  25. Pingback: Obama’s “Palestinian Land” | FirstOneThrough

  26. Pingback: “Settlements” Crossing the Line | FirstOneThrough

  27. Pingback: Nikki Haley Will Not Equivocate on the Ecosystem of Violence | FirstOneThrough

  28. Pingback: Heritage, Property and Sovereignty in the Holy Land | FirstOneThrough

  29. Pingback: Israel Plans to Build in Israeli Territory. It’s News | FirstOneThrough

  30. Pingback: Grenzüberschreitende „Siedlungen” – Politisches

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s