The Left-Wing’s Two State Solution: 1.5 States for Arabs, 0.5 for Jews

The two state-solution for the “Question of Palestine” has been bandied about for decades. At the 1993 Oslo Accords, the Israelis and Palestinian Arabs seemingly came to a conclusion that there would be a division of the land, one for Arabs and one for Jews. However, when the negotiations reached a critical juncture in September 2000, the head of the Palestinian Authority Yasser Arafat (fungus be upon him), opted to terminate the peace process and launched another war of terrorism against the Jewish State.

Fifteen-plus years and several thousands of dead and injured later, the concept of a two state solution still lingers. While in principle the concept harkens back to the 1947 United Nations Partition plan of two states for two peoples, the radical left has pushed aggressively for a different configuration of two states to the liking of Palestinian Arabs: one and one-half states for Arabs, and one-half of a state for Jews.

The 1.5 Arab States

The 100% Arab State of Palestine. Palestinian Arabs are seeking a new country which will be devoid of any Jews. Acting President of the Palestinian Authority made his demand clear in July 2013. His declaration is consistent with every action taken by Palestinian Arabs over the years:

  • Palestinian laws which make it a crime for any Arab to sell land to a Jew (consistent with Jordanian law);
  • Jordanian law specifically excluded Jews from the “West Bank”/ east of the Green Line (EGL) being granted citizenship;
  • Demand that any and all Jews be removed from EGL (including Jews who live in existing homes that have been around for decades);
  • No Jewish visitor on Palestinian college campuses (Bir Zeit);
  • No Jewish businesses may operate in the disputed territories

These demands are blessed by several radical left-wing Jewish groups. Groups like Jewish Voice for Peace, Independent Jewish Voices (Canada), and European Jews for a Just Peace, advocate for BDS (boycott, divestment and sanctions) for any business that operates east of the Green Line (EGL) and in Israel itself. Individuals like Rabbi Ellen Lippmann on the board of J Street, also see no problems with BDS for Jews living in EGL.

Non-Jewish left-wing radicals take note of the Jewish positions.  US President Obama has not just called new Israeli towns in EGL “illegitimate,” but argued that no Jews should be permitted to live in EGL, even in homes they legally purchase such as in SIlwan, in eastern Jerusalem.  Author Tuvia Tenenbom noted that Europeans and others need not be openly anti-Semitic anymore; they can just fund the rabidly anti-Zionist Jewish groups that bless a Judefrei Palestine.

Silwan YemeniteDSC_1020
Top picture: Silwan, in eastern Jerusalem, founded by Yemenite Jews
(photo: late 19th Century)
Bottom picture: mostly Arab Silwan in 2013
(photo: First.One.Through)

The 50% Arab State of Israel. Other left-wing groups like Adalah (supported by the New Israel Fund), seek to dismantle the Jewish State and replace it with a bi-cultural state. They advocate for the removal of anything associated with Judaism such as the Jewish symbols on the flag, in front of the Knesset and in the national anthem.

The left-wing groups are also against any Jewish preferences in Israel, such as the Law of Return which enables Jews from around the world to become citizens of Israel on an expedited basis.  The revised neutral state of Israel would have Jews living as a minority, as the Palestinian Arab Right of Return would bring millions of Arabs into this bi-cultural state.

In the end, the Holy Land would have a completely Arab, Jew-free state called “Palestine,” and a second democratic, bi-cultural state where Arabs would be a majority, but where Jews would be allowed to live.

150% of the “Holy Basin” for Arabs.
The non-holy 50% for Jews

The 1.5 Arab states in the holy land would also have 150% of the “Holy Basin,” and all of the region’s holy sites.

When the United Nations first drafted a partition plan in 1947, it considered the two holy cities – Jerusalem and Bethlehem – to be a “Holy Basin” which would be part of neither state. As the left-wing now pushes for the 150% Arab plan, they are advancing a radical plan for the Holy Basin.

1947plan jerusalem
UN 1947 Partition Plan for the “Holy Basin”
of Greater Jerusalem and Greater Bethlehem

100% of Bethlehem. As part of the Oslo Accords, Israel handed over control of the City of Bethlehem to the Palestinian Authority at the end of 1995. Israel only maintains a small presence at Judaism’s third holiest site, the Tomb of Rachel. After Arafat’s Second Intifada, the Israelis were forced to create a wall around the small tomb to protect Jewish visitors.  In general, the city is now virtually devoid of Jews and Christians since coming under the Palestinian Authority.

The Holy 50% of Jerusalem. The Palestinian Authority demands that the entirety of the Old City of Jerusalem, which contains Judaism’s holiest sites, Islam’s third holiest site, and many Christian holy sites, all be part of the Palestinian capital. It is content to let the newer part of the city to the west, which has no holy sites, to be the capital of Israel.

The radical left endorses the Palestinian Arab plan.

The fact that only Israel has allowed freedoms of access and religion in Jerusalem does not sway people who claim to seek “justice.”  Groups which claim to advance “human rights,” advocate for an anti-Semitic Jew-free agenda in Palestine.  Further, using the maxim that the best defense is a good offense, these groups consider anyone that points out the bias of their plan and impracticality of diving a capital city to be right-wing racists.

The joys of being a radical liberal is that you can feel 150% morally superior while waving banners of “justice” and “human rights”, even while trampling on those very principles.

Related First.One.Through articles:

The Israeli Peace Process versus the Palestinian Divorce Proceedings

The Arguments over Jerusalem

Squeezing Zionism

“Peace” According to Palestinian “Moderates”

Liberals’ Biggest Enemies of 2015

Israel, the Liberal Country of the Middle East

Today’s Inverted Chanukah: The Holiday of Rights in Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria

Subscribe YouTube channel: FirstOneThrough

Join Facebook group: FirstOne Through  Israel Analysis

31 thoughts on “The Left-Wing’s Two State Solution: 1.5 States for Arabs, 0.5 for Jews

  1. Pingback: J Street: Going Bigger and Bolder than BDS | FirstOneThrough

  2. Pingback: J Street’s Select Appreciation of Transparency | FirstOneThrough

  3. Pingback: The Illogic of Land Swaps | FirstOneThrough

  4. Pingback: Bernie Sanders is the Worst U.S. Presidential Candidate for Israel Ever | FirstOneThrough

  5. Pingback: Thomas Friedman Thinks Palestinians are Crazy in the Margins, While Israel is Crazy in the Mainstream | FirstOneThrough

  6. Pingback: The UN’s Ban Ki Moon Ignores Civilians Killed by the US and KSA | FirstOneThrough

  7. Pingback: Black Lives Matter Joins the anti-Israel “Progressives” Fighting Zionism | FirstOneThrough

  8. Pingback: “Ethnic Cleansing” in Israel and the Israeli Territories | FirstOneThrough

  9. Pingback: Obama’s “Palestinian Land” | FirstOneThrough

  10. Pingback: The Many Lies of Jimmy Carter | FirstOneThrough

  11. Pingback: The Reform Movement Has no Understanding of Tolerance | FirstOneThrough

  12. Pingback: The Evil Architect’s at J Street Take a Bow | FirstOneThrough

  13. Pingback: A Seder in Jerusalem with Liberal Friends | FirstOneThrough

  14. Pingback: Students for Justice in Palestine’s Dick Pics | FirstOneThrough

  15. Pingback: The Non-Orthodox Jewish Denominations Fight Israel | FirstOneThrough

  16. Pingback: Maybe Truman Should Not Have Recognized Israel | FirstOneThrough

  17. Pingback: Thomas Friedman is a Peddler of Racist Fiction and Adolescent Fantasy | FirstOneThrough

  18. Pingback: Vielleicht hätte Truman Israel nicht anerkennen sollen | abseits vom mainstream - heplev

  19. Pingback: This July 4, I am Leaving the Democratic Party that Left Me Long Ago | FirstOneThrough

  20. Pingback: Deciphering the 2018 Basic Law in Israel – The Nation State of the Jewish People | FirstOneThrough

  21. Pingback: The Basic Law’s “Unique” Problem | FirstOneThrough

  22. Pingback: Taking it Straight to the People: Obama and Kushner | FirstOneThrough

  23. Pingback: Ayman Odeh Doesn’t Speak for Arab Israelis, Jewish Israelis or Peace | FirstOneThrough

  24. Pingback: J Street is Only Considered “Pro-Israel” in Progressive Circles | FirstOneThrough

  25. Pingback: While Lying About Israel, Democrats Demand Nothing of Palestinians | FirstOneThrough

  26. Pingback: JVP and J Street Attack Foreign Affairs Committee | FirstOneThrough

  27. Pingback: Jewish Voice for Peace Ignores Dead Jews | FirstOneThrough

  28. Pingback: NY Times Dislikes ‘Judaizing’ Israel | FirstOneThrough

  29. Pingback: Enduring Peace Requires Unity AND Tolerance | FirstOneThrough

  30. Pingback: Settlements For Peace | FirstOneThrough

  31. Pingback: The Anti-Semitism In Anti-Zionism | FirstOneThrough

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s