Summary: According to Muslims, the Temple Mount is held in “trusteeship” by the Islamic Waqf, which assures its use and access as a mosque. The role of the Waqf has nothing to do with sovereignty of the land on which it resides.
The most sensitive issue of the Israel-Arab conflict is considered to be the Temple Mount in Jerusalem.
The Temple Mount is a 35 acre platform that held the second Jewish Temple from around 515CE to 70CE. Herod extended the platform on which the Temple sat southward to enable the greater flow of the thousands of Jews that came to the Temple to perform their rituals. The platform extension project ran from 19BCE to 63CE and Jews enjoyed the benefit of his work until the Romans destroyed the Temple in 70CE.
The Old City of Jerusalem, including Jewish Quarter and Temple Mount
The area is considered sacred to Muslims as they believe Mohammed had a night journey from Saudi Arabia on a flying horse to that location before ascending to heaven. When Arabs invaded Jerusalem in 627CE, they built the al Aqsa Mosque on the southern edge of Temple Mount (completed in 705CE and rebuilt in 1033) to commemorate the importance of the location. The other structures on the Temple Mount include the Dome of the Rock, the Dome of the Chain, the Dome of the Prophet and various other structures which are NOT mosques, but shrines.
Jews had access and were able to pray on the Temple Mount until around the year 1550, when Suleiman I began a series of “improvements” to Jerusalem. He ordered the rebuilding of the city walls and moved the Jews off of the mount to an area now referred to as the “Kotel” or “Wailing Wall” or “Western Wall”, a sliver of the western retaining wall built by Herod. Since that time, prayer on the Mount has been restricted only for Muslim use.
Five Arab armies attacked Israel at its founding in 1948. At the end of the war in 1949, Jerusalem became divided with the western half (almost all completely established since the 1850s) under Israeli sovereignty, and the eastern half (including the Old City dating back 4000 years) under Jordanian sovereignty (which was not recognized by the United Nations). The Jordanians evicted all of the Jews and barred their reentry, even to visit their holy sites, counter to the Fourth Geneva Convention.
In 1967, the Jordanians again attacked Israel. They lost the eastern half of Jerusalem and all of Judea and Samaria, which they had annexed in 1950. Israel reunified the city and made clear that people of all religions – not just Jews – would have access and rights to their holy places. Non-Muslims were once again allowed onto the platform, and Israel gave administrative oversight of the Temple Mount compound to the Jordanian Waqf. Israel annexed the area and the rest of eastern Jerusalem in a move not recognized globally.
In 1988, Jordan gave up all claims to lands it lost to Israel in the 1967 war, and signed a peace treaty with Israel in 1994. In that peace agreement, several key clauses were added to address Jerusalem, Article 9:
- Each Party will provide freedom of access to places of religious and historical significance.
- In this regard, in accordance with the Washington Declaration, Israel respects the present special role of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan in Muslim Holy shrines in Jerusalem. When negotiations on the permanent status will take place, Israel will give high priority to the Jordanian historic role in these shrines.
- The Parties will act together to promote interfaith relations among the three monotheistic religions, with the aim of working towards religious understanding, moral commitment, freedom of religious worship, and tolerance and peace.
Jews Praying at the Kotel, 2015
Islam allows Muslims to place property (land or any object) into a “Waqf”. By doing so, the item comes under the trusteeship of the party specified in the declaration. In the case of the al Aqsa Mosque, the building is considered to be for the public use of all Muslims under the administration of the Jordanian Waqf.
When the al Aqsa mosque was taken over by Crusaders in the 12th century, the place did not lose its special status for Muslims. As stated in Issue 2697: ““If the Waqfed property is ruined, its position as Waqf is not affected, except when the Waqf is of a special nature, and that special feature ceases to exist. For example, if a person endows a garden and the garden is ruined, the Waqf becomes void and the garden reverts to the heirs of the person.”
Properties or entities like the Old City of Jerusalem or the Temple Mount itself can be subdivided according to Islam. As written in Issue 2698: “If one part of a property has been waqfed and the other part is not, and the property is undivided, the Mujtahid, or the trustee of the Waqf, or the beneficiaries can divide the property and separate the Waqf part in consultation with the experts.”
As described above, the Jordanian Waqf took control of the Temple Mount in 1949 and Israel has continued to let the Waqf administer the site. The Jordanian Waqf now employs 500 people to run the mosque. It does this, while Israel maintains all security controls and runs it as part and parcel of Israel.
It would appear that the actions of 1967, 1988 and 1994 laid the groundwork for a sharing of the Temple Mount between Jews and Muslims again. However, it has continued to be a struggle.
POLITICS and PROPAGANDA
Over the last few years, the Waqf has become more politicized, anti-Jewish and anti-Israel, as it was decades ago. Public statements from the Waqf:
- Deny Jewish history at the Temple Mount
- Attempt to deny Jewish rights of access
- Deny Jewish rights to prayer (agreed to by the Israeli government)
- Deny sovereignty of the Jewish State and Jerusalem municipality (agreed by many countries in the United Nations)
Consider a recent discovery of ancient Judaica near the Temple Mount. The Waqf issued a statement that the findings were “an attempt to support Israeli claims about Jewish rights in the holy city and to impose Israeli sovereignty on the occupied holy compound through the use of fake evidence….An immediate Arab and Muslim campaign is needed to stop the Israeli attempts to Judaise the holy city of Jerusalem,”
Discovery of Jewish artifacts at base of Temple Mount
dating to period before creation of Islam
It is interesting that the Waqf would make a claim of “Judaising” the city of Jerusalem which has had a Jewish majority for 150 years. It was also this same Jordanian Waqf that participated in expelling Jews from the Old City of Jerusalem and barring their entry from 1949-1967.
PEACE ON THE TEMPLE MOUNT
Israel’s perspective: Israel has sought a peaceful situation on the Temple Mount from the very beginning of reunifying Jerusalem. In 1967, Moshe Dayan announced: “To our Arab neighbors we extend, especially at this hour, the hand of peace. To members of the other religions, Christians and Muslims, I hereby promise faithfully that their full freedom and all their religious rights will be preserved. We did not come to Jerusalem to conquer the Holy Places of others.”
The declaration was followed by the establishment of the Protection of Holy Places Law which ensured the rights of all religions to pray at their holy sites.
Today, in an effort to appease the extremist views of the Waqf, radical Palestinians and the Jordanian government itself which threated to break its peace treaty with Israel, the Israeli government has continued to enforce a ban on Jewish prayer on the Mount.
Muslims’ Perspective: Suleiman pushed the Jews off of the Temple Mount in 1550 and Jordanian Arabs expelled the Jews from the entire Old City in 1949. Muslims and Arabs would clearly prefer that there be no Jews in Jerusalem.
However, according to Islam, there is no conflict with the Temple Mount being completely under Israeli sovereignty as detailed above.
According to the Peace Treaty between Israel and Jordan, the Temple Mount (outside of al Aqsa Mosque) should permit non-Mulsim prayer, despite Jordan’s recent protests.
Israel has continued to extend its full hand to share the Temple Mount. Meanwhile, the Arab world took initial steps some decades ago to recognize Jewish history and rights which do not conflict with Islamic law. Regrettably, recent history has witnessed a more hostile Arab approach.
Perhaps the future will witness peace on the Temple Mount with full access and rights for Jews at their holiest location.
Waqf rules: http://www.al-islam.org/islamic-laws-ayatullah-ali-al-husayni-al-sistani/rules-regarding-waqf
Noble Sanctuary: http://www.noblesanctuary.com/AQSAMosque.html
Palestinian women fight Jews on Temple Mount: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/17/world/middleeast/palestinian-women-join-effort-to-keep-jews-from-contested-holy-site.html
Related First One Through articles:
Sharing the Temple Mount like the Cave of Patriarchs
Five holy sites in the holy land
Palestinians are “desperate”… but for what?
Palestinian Arabs control of Jerusalem for 0.5% of its history
Pingback: Emanuel Winston Archives |
Pingback: The Arguments over Jerusalem | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Losing the Temples, Knowledge and Caring | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Names and Narrative: CNN’s Temple Mount/ Al Aqsa Complex Inversion | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: The UN’s Disinterest of Jewish Rights at Jewish Holy Places | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Jordan’s Deceit and Hunger for Control of Jerusalem | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Visitor Rights on the Temple Mount | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: It is Time to Insert “Jewish” into the Names of the Holy Sites | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: It’s the Temple Mount, Not the Western Wall | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: UNESCO Votes after only Hearing the Opposition | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Time for King Abdullah of Jordan to Denounce the Mourabitoun | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Is Trump Seeing Mid-East Countries to Combat Religious Extremism, or Visiting Religious Sites to Promote Coexistence? | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Will Israel Also Remove an Umbrella from the Western Wall Plaza? | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Oh Abdullah, Jordan is Not So Special | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: The Invisible Flag in Judo and Jerusalem | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Ending Apartheid in Jerusalem | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Ending Apartheid in Jerusalem | Bible Prophecy In The Daily Headlines
Pingback: Die Apartheid in Jerusalem beenden | abseits vom mainstream - heplev
Pingback: A Sofer at the Kotel | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: The Mourabitat Women of Congress | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Jerusalem’s Old City Is a Religious War for Muslim Arabs | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: The Dark Side of Jerusalem Day: Magnifying the Kotel and Minimizing the Temple Mount | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: There is No Temple Mount for The New York Times | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Replacing the Jordanian Waqf on The Temple Mount | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: The Zionists Brought a Bench! | FirstOneThrough
Pingback: Time for Jordan To Live Up To Its Peace Treaty With Israel And Support Jewish Prayer On The Temple Mount | FirstOneThrough